AMITYVILLE II:
THE POSSESSION
MOVIE REVIEW

Movies Eddie McMullen Jr. Review by
E.C.McMullen Jr.
Amityville II
THE AMITYVILLE HORROR
PREQUELS, SEQUELS, and
REMAKES

AMITYVILLE II: THE POSSESSION

- 1982
U.S.A. Release: September, 24 1982
Dino de Laurentiis Cinematografica, Media Transactions
Rated: Finland: K16 / France: 12 / Germany: 16 / Sweden: 15 / U.K.: 18 / USA: R

Directed by Damiano Damiani
Written by Tommy Lee Wallace, Hans Holzer
Starring James Olson, Burt Young, Rutanya Alda, Diane Franklin, Moses Gunn

That Ronald DeFeo Jr. was convicted of murdering his parents and siblings on the night of November 13, 1974 is true. To this day Ronald denies it, and even fields thenightexposed.net/.1

But what Jay Anson (THE AMITYVILLE HORROR - 1977) and Hans Holzer (MURDER IN AMITYVILLE - 1979) tried to pass off as truth in the 1970s, remains pure hokum.

Where the first THE AMITYVILLE HORROR was taken from the Jay Anson novel, AMITYVILLE II: POSSESSION, is from the Hans Holzer book, which is about the DeFeo family. In this movie, however, they are not called DeFeo, but Montelli, and Ronny DeFeo is now Sonny. Coming right on the heels of the first AMITYVILLE, this movie is sort of like a slingshot effect. Stretch the story back past where the first story began kinda prequel thing.

TRIVIA

UPDATES: Murderer, Ronald deFeo Jr. (no relation) died in prison, March 12, 2021.

Hans Holzer lived long enough to see himself thoroughly debunked, including his fake Ph.D. He died April 26, 2009 in Manhattan, NY.

1 Some of the Amityville Horror is true and the folks who chose to involve themselves with it long after the fact, continue to fight over it to this very day.

WARNING:
Many of these sites claim that they are the "official site".

The Participants

Amityville Horror Truth

The Amityville Horror
(hosted by the real George Lutz)

UPDATES: Kathy Lutz died of emphysema on August 17, 2004 in Scottsdale, AZ, during production on the 2005 version of THE AMITYVILLE HORROR.

Her husband, George died of heart disease on May 8, 2006 in Las Vegas, NV.

The Amityville Murders

Of course, anything this popular will have self-styled psychics, paranormal investigators, and paranormal researchers coming out of the woodwork. Here's one.

The Warrens

UPDATE: Self-certified "Demonologist", Ed Warren, died August 23, 2007.
Self-certified "Clairvoyant", Lorraine Warren, died April 18, 2019.

The Debunkers

Prairie Ghosts

Snopes

Wikipedia

We begin in 1974.

The - ahem - Montelli family arrives at their new home. Patriarch Anthony Montelli (Burt Young: CARNIVAL OF BLOOD, HACK!) looks about, disappointed in their new and beautiful mansion of a home in Long Island New York; in a little suburb called Amityville.

His wife Dolores (Rutanya Alda: THE FURY, WHEN A STRANGER CALLS [1979], THE STUFF, THE DARK HALF, THE GLASS HOUSE) and daughter Patricia (Diane Franklin: TERROR VISION) see the house and get all excited, singing to each other in glee until Anthony threatens them ("Shaddap afore I raps yez all in da mout!").

The oldest son, Sonny (Jack Magner: FIRESTARTER) shows up and Anthony walks over to the car and starts threatening HIM ("Hey! You want me to rap yez in da mout?"). Basically, Anthony is an unrepentant selfish asshole and Burt Young was picked for this part to basically revise and repeat his role as Paulie from Rocky.

For the longest time, nothing scary happens. Not even anything that should be scary. This is largely due to the family dynamic where Anthony is so damn violent and prone to rage ("You wants I should rap yez all in da mout?") that he's a far greater danger to everyone than any ghosts in the house ("No Papa! Don't rap us all in da mout!").

It's already a freaky Catholic family anyway. There is brother and sister incest (relax, no nudity worth mentioning - a quick nipple shot is hardly worth mentioning unless yer pretty damn desperate), and the almost non-stop rage of Anthony.

Eventually the house starts picking on Anthony specifically and he loses his marbles in no time flat. Which is too bad because by this point we're ready to see the whole family die. Sonny achieves this and then the movie gets to be about what it's really about, the exorcism of the demon within Sonny. Only thing is, we don't care about Sonny or the hammy acting of James Olson (THE ANDROMEDA STRAIN).

I grant you, the direction by Damiano Damiani (A STREGA IN AMORE) is no great shakes and he even made Moses Gunn appear awful. A screenplay from Tommy Lee Wallace (HALLOWEEN III: SEASON OF THE WITCH, FRIGHT NIGHT PART 2, s [1990], VAMPIRES: LOS MUERTOS) that feels like a first draft adaptation of Hans Holzer's book, further exacerbates the awful. Still James Olson had the biggest role here, playing Catholic Priest, Father Adamsky, as a self-appointed exorcist (his church is dead-set against him even trying it. He's not a properly trained one). Olson and Damiani go to the well way too many times with Olson looking directly at the camera and shouting things like,

"Unclean spirit!"

Not the approach I'd take. Words can hurt and I'm more of a "Kill 'em with Kindness" kinda guy. Shouting insults at the demon is not going to make it listen to reason, let alone consider personal hygiene.

So Father Adamsky tries to convince Police Detective Turner (Moses Gunn: THE NINTH CONFIGURATION, FIRESTARTER) to let him take Sonny out of jail and perform an exorcism.

Sheesh! The plotholes, devices, and stupidity yawn ever wider before this flick is through. The only thing that stops this from being a tiresome TV movie is the flash of nipple and some poorly created gore. That doesn't save it though.

One Shriek Girl.

Shriek Girls
This review copyright 2008 E.C.McMullen Jr.

Amityville II: The Possession (1982) on IMDb
GET SOME CLOTHES ON
YOU MIGHT ALSO ENJOY
(Sub-Section: GHOSTS - MODERN)
The Sixth Sense the Legend of Hell House Dark Water 2002
THE SIXTH SENSE
MOVIE REVIEW
THE LEGEND OF HELL HOUSE
MOVIE REVIEW
DARK WATER
MOVIE REVIEW

Return to Movies

FEO AMANTE'S HORROR THRILLER
Created by:
E.C.McMullen Jr.
FOLLOW ME @
Amazon
ECMJr
Feo Blog
IMDb
Instagram
Stage32
Twitter X
YouTube
Zazzle Shop